Should you cash out refinance or take out a home equity line of credit?

So you have a situation in which you need to access cash. You have a first mortgage at 3%, lots of equity in your home and you want to cash out refinance in order to do a new improvement. What’s the best way to access that money?..

The reality of it is you pretty much have three choices. Wait, do a second mortgage, or do a cash-out refinance. Those are the only three choices.  You don’t want to give up a 3% mortgage on a cash-out refinance, but you also don’t like the idea of having an adjustable-rate loan either. Well, you have to be comfortable with the temporary prospect of being uncomfortable. More specifically here’s what this means… Your first option is to just wait and not do anything and hope long-term interest rates come down which they will, but no one knows when that’s going to be. That could be another year out or longer, it also could be sooner. Another option is to take out a home equity line of credit. These are pricey averaging around 10% with most, but not all banks.  This loan choice is essentially like a giant credit card tied to your home. You only pay interest on the current loan balance.
The problem with this loan is it is a variable rate that moves in alignment with the prime rate. If the prime rate continues to go up, the payment on this type of loan rises if you carry a balance. Ten percent interest is not cheap money by any stretch of the means. Another alternative to cash-out refinance is to take out a new first mortgage, in the mid-six percent range. This means giving up your 3% loan knowing however, that the payment is fixed, and if the payments on this might actually end up being almost the same as a home equity line of credit, without having the adjustable-rate payment component that a home equity line of credit does.

At the end of the day, it may boil down to whatever helps you sleep at night, but more specifically things can get sometimes a little bit murky. If you have the financial ability to pay off the home equity line of credit very quickly within 12 months, so you have zero balance, that might not be a bad thing to consider however, if you don’t have the economic means to pay off the home, equity line of credit balance, within 12 months, doing a new first mortgage might be a better solution altogether, knowing that you could always refinance ith long-term interest rates, lowering in the future. Know that whatever direction you decide to go long-term interest rates are poised to come down allowing you to potentially refinance the loan in the future lower your interest rate and lower your monthly payment as a result.

Looking to cash out your mortgage loan? Get a no-cost quote today!

RELATED MORTGAGE ADVICE FROM SCOTT SHELDON

Illustration of a house with a dollar sign on one side and a stack of investment charts on the other, representing the choice between paying off a mortgage and investing

Should you pay off your mortgage or invest the cash instead?

When you come into extra cash—whether from a bonus, inheritance, or years of disciplined saving—you…

Illustration of a parent holding a child and mortgage documents, symbolizing using child support income to qualify for a mortgage.

How to Use Child Support Income to Qualify for a Mortgage

For many homebuyers, every source of income matters when qualifying for a mortgage. If you…

Can You Use Section 8 Vouchers to Buy a Home? Yes — Here's How

Can You Use Section 8 Vouchers to Buy a Home? Yes — Here’s How

If you’re receiving Section 8 housing assistance and think that owning a home is out…

ustration of a house split into two halves—one side showing dollar bills representing cash flow and the other side showing an upward graph arrow representing property appreciation.

Should you buy rental property for cash flow or appreciation?

When you invest in real estate, one of the first decisions you face is whether…

View More from The Mortgage Files:

begin your mortgage journey with sonoma county mortgages

Let us make your mortgage experience easy. Trust our expertise to get you your best mortgage rate. Click below to start turning your home dreams into reality today!