Should you do a cash-out refinance or get a home equity line of credit?

As mortgage rates continue to remain flat, it might not be a bad thing to consider really weighing out both options of getting a home equity line of credit or doing a Cash out refinance for that home improvement project or debt consolidation you have been thinking about. If you’re looking to pull money out of your house, consider your options first…

Home equity lines of credit are low cost to acquire sometimes no cost. If you ever close out the home equity line of credit you may incur an early closure fee. A home equity line of credit is effectively an enormous credit card tied to your house. You only pay interest on any present balance which means that it can sit there with no balance as a safety cushion, if you ever need to borrow money it is at your disposal.

Any payment that you make on the home equity line of credit for the first 10 years is interest only. Meaning your balance will never go down unless you make an overage payment and the additional money that you pay beyond your interest only payment goes toward principal. These loans are also variable rate tied to the prime rate.

Mortgage tip: these loans are no longer tax deductible.

Cash-out refinancing your first mortgage instead as an alternative to a home equity line of credit might not be such a bad thing. The closing costs might be about 1% of your loan amount maybe depending on your area and specific location. The interest rate is higher, but also is tax deductible. A 30-year mortgage also means having a lower payment for your debt. If you were to compare a fixed rate 30-year term to a home equity line of credit plus a first mortgage you might come to find that the payments for both are about the same or maybe as little as fifty bucks a month more (in some cases) for the comfort of having a long-term fixed-rate loan.

Most consumers would probably stand to benefit by being able to deduct more interest as a byproduct of cash-out refinancing their home to fix up their house or doing a debt consolidation for example then they would taking a home equity line of credit that is not tax-deductible and has a variable payment associated with it.

Therefore, it is critical to work with an experienced lender who can walk you through the ins-and-outs of deciding whether a fixed rate mortgage makes sense or whether home equity line of credit is a more suitable choice for you and your payment and cash flow objectives.

Looking to refinance? Get a no cost quote now.

RELATED MORTGAGE ADVICE FROM SCOTT SHELDON

Should You Buy a Rental Property for Cash Flow or Appreciation?

Cash flow and appreciation can both build wealth through rental real estate, but they work differently. Learn how to balance income, equity, financing, and tax planning.

Rate Buydowns in Sonoma County: What Buyers Need to Know in 2026

Rate buydowns can lower a Sonoma County home payment, but temporary and permanent options work very differently. Learn what to compare before you commit.

How to Buy a Home With a Financed Down Payment

A financed down payment program may help qualified buyers purchase with little or no down payment. Learn the payment tradeoffs and who it may fit.

How to Get an FHA Loan After a Six-Month Employment Gap

An FHA loan may still be possible after a lengthy job gap. Learn the six-month return-to-work rule, the two-year work history requirement, and how timing affects a purchase or refinance.

View More from The Mortgage Files:

Row edge-slant Shape Decorative svg added to top
Row edge-slant Shape Decorative svg added to bottom

begin your mortgage journey with sonoma county mortgages

Let us make your mortgage experience easy. Trust our expertise to get you your best mortgage rate. Click below to start turning your home dreams into reality today!