How to evaluate buying a rental property

Buying a rental property can be very lucrative and sound financial vestment. Here’s how to determine whether not buying a rental property with financing makes sense.

Location, location, location

Location for the property is critical. It is often thought a rental property is more dollars and cents transaction with less focus on location. While this is generally true, a rental property in a fantastic location will always have strong rents, less vacancy, and much better appreciation over time compared with a property that has better cash flow in a less desirable location.

Get real about repairs

Generally, it is a good bet when you can buy a rental property where the rent is greater than the mortgage payment turning your cash flow positive. It is a good idea to allocate at least 5% of the gross rents for the inevitable repairs that you’re going to incur as a landlord. This includes, but it not limited to:

  • new roof
  • new gutter and or repair
  • new paint
  • new kitchen
  • various repairs

Return on investment

How much cash will it take to earn x return is critical. Rate of return (ROI) is your net (after expenses) annual income divided by the capital investment. For example if your net income is 1k per month and your cash to buy a rental is $100k (down payment + closing costs). $12k ÷ $100k = 12% return. Each property will have a different rate of return. What’s the best return to aim for? That depends on your appetite for risk, cash on hand and revenue potential the property the property has.

Property type

This one is big and is by far the most important decision you need to make. For our purposes we are looking at a single-family homes, condominiums and multi-family properties. Here is the list from best to worst-multi-family properties almost always pencil better than a single-family homes. A multi-family home is essentially getting several single-family homes for one.

Here’s the eye popping part for landlords to hone in on, buying a rental such as a duplex allows the landlord to have flexibility when there’s a vacancy. If one unit is vacant the other unit makes up for the loss and vice versa. The combination of more units means more revenue driving potential returns higher.

A single-family homes in a great location can be a sound financial investment. However, if you have a vacancy, you don’t have another unit to offset loss of rent unless you have a single-family home with a granny unit. The granny unit can help offset that negative rental impact on the vacancy. Single-family homes can be solid financial investments as long as you do your due homework.

Condominiums are last on the list as they are the last to appreciate and the first to depreciate in economic cycles. Additionally, you’re sharing units with other owners which makes the income potential is very limited compared to a single-family home or a multi-family property. Taking it a step further, the homeowners association payment can be anywhere between two hundred and four hundred per month. This is a big chunk of your cash flow that otherwise could be used to plan for upkeep or pay a property manager.

Consider the following when evaluating whether a rental makes sense for you:

  • Is the property in a good location that would generate solid revenue and always be desirable?
  • If it’s not in a good location, how much better is my ROI?
  • Is this a property that will need minimal or manageable upkeep over the bigger picture?
  • Remember older properties need more upkeep.
  • How is this benefiting me financially?

As a good rule of thumb make sure you understand all the figures associated with this high ticket investment. The better handle you have on the numbers, the better success you will have purchasing a solid rental property.

Looking to buy a rental? Get a quote now.

RELATED MORTGAGE ADVICE FROM SCOTT SHELDON

A wallet containing colorful credit cards with a bold text overlay reading "Refinancing Strategies to Reduce Credit Card Debt and Buy a Home – Refinance" against a blue background.

Refinancing Strategies to Reduce Credit Card Debt and Buy a Home

Refinancing Strategies to Reduce Credit Card Debt and Buy a Home If you’re sitting on…

"How Seller Credits Can Help You Maximize Savings on FHA and Conventional Loans" explaining what seller credits are, how they can be used for closing costs or interest rate buy-downs, the FHA 6% seller credit allowance, and a comparison table of conventional loan seller credit limits based on down payment. Includes a pie chart showing a split of 3% used for closing costs and 3% for interest rate buy-down.

How seller credit maximize your purchasing power on a conventional or FHA home loan

Maximizing Your Home Buying Power with Seller Credits When purchasing a home, every dollar counts.…

When buying a home, it’s natural to want the lowest mortgage rate possible. But sometimes, chasing a slightly better rate from another lender—especially after your offer has already been accepted—can backfire in a big way. Let’s walk through a real-world scenario. You’ve got an offer accepted on a house. You’re working with a lender who has you approved, documents in underwriting, and a 21-day close of escrow in place. Everything is moving forward. Then you hear from another lender offering a rate that’s 0.25% lower, with slightly better closing costs. It’s tempting. But before you make a jump, here’s what you need to consider. Switching Lenders Comes with Time Costs When you pivot to a new lender mid-contract, they’ll need to: Re-underwrite your entire loan, Order a new appraisal, Disclose and sign new loan documents, Submit the file for final loan approval, Schedule and fund closing—all over again. This doesn’t happen overnight. Even in ideal circumstances, the new lender is likely going to need at least 25–30 days to close. If you’re in a fast-moving or competitive market, this is a real problem. Most sellers won’t grant a contract extension just because you’re switching lenders. So, what happens next? A Contract Extension Can Jeopardize Your Deal Asking for a contract extension means the seller must agree to delay closing. But that delay introduces risk—especially if the seller has backup offers or simply wants certainty. They may not grant the extension. Or worse, they could cancel the deal outright and take another buyer’s offer. Even if the seller agrees to extend, your earnest money and negotiation power could take a hit. And for what? A slightly lower rate that might save you $50 to $75 a month? Mortgage Rates Aren’t as Far Apart as You Think Here’s the truth: all mortgage lenders get their money from the same place—the bond market. The pricing differences between lenders usually range from 0.125% to 0.25% in rate on any given day. If one lender seems to be offering dramatically better pricing, the first thing you should ask is: How? Head over to FreddieMac.com and check the average 30-year fixed rate posted weekly. This is one of the most reliable benchmarks for where rates truly stand in the market. If a lender is quoting you a rate that’s well below that average, ask for the details: Are they charging extra points? Is this a teaser rate with a prepayment penalty? Is it based on a different loan product or risky structure? Often, what sounds “too good to be true”… is. Consider the Bigger Picture Think long-term. If you’re financing $600,000, a 0.25% lower rate may reduce your payment by roughly $75/month. But what if you lose the house and have to start over? That monthly savings doesn’t mean much if you’re outbid on your dream home or lose your deposit. Also, remember: you’re not going to keep this rate forever. Today’s homebuyers typically refinance when rates drop by about 0.75% or more. So if rates fall within the next year or two, you’ll likely be refinancing anyway. Instead of paying extra points now or risking the entire deal for a minor monthly savings, it may be better to accept a slightly higher rate—knowing you’ll refinance when the time is right. The Real Risk Isn’t the Rate—It’s the Delay When shopping for a home loan, don’t just ask, “What’s your rate?” Ask: Can you close on time? Is this rate sustainable or based on hidden costs? Will switching lenders delay or jeopardize my contract? A home purchase contract is a binding agreement between you and the seller to perform within a set timeframe. If you can’t meet those dates because you're chasing a slightly better rate elsewhere, you may want to reconsider if now is the right time to buy. Final Thoughts Yes, interest rates matter. But execution matters more. Before making a switch mid-transaction, talk to your lender. Have an honest conversation about pricing, timelines, and strategy. You might find that staying the course, securing the house, and planning to refinance later offers a better path to financial security. Want to Know Your Options? Let’s compare rates and strategies the smart way—without risking your dream home. 👉 Click here to get a custom rate quote today.

The Risks of Chasing a Lower Mortgage Rate

Why Chasing a Lower Mortgage Rate Can Backfire When buying a home, it’s natural to…

A woman sitting at a kitchen table looking through documents with an American flag and framed military photo beside her, symbolizing a surviving spouse exploring VA loan options.

VA Loan Options for Surviving Spouses

Understanding VA Loan Refinance Options for Surviving Spouses Losing a spouse is one of life’s…

View More from The Mortgage Files:

begin your mortgage journey with sonoma county mortgages

Let us make your mortgage experience easy. Trust our expertise to get you your best mortgage rate. Click below to start turning your home dreams into reality today!