When Mortgage Rates Actually Fall (And Why That Hasn’t Happened Yet)

Over the past week, there has been a lot of noise around mortgage rates. Headlines moved fast, social media lit up, and many buyers and homeowners were left wondering the same thing: “Are rates finally coming down?”

The short answer, as of mid-January, is no. Mortgage rates are essentially unchanged.

Last week, President Trump made public comments about wanting Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to begin purchasing billions of dollars of mortgage-backed securities. When that news first hit the market, interest rates briefly improved. For a moment, it looked like we might finally see some relief.

Then the market whipped right back.

Rates moved up just as quickly as they moved down, landing almost exactly where they started. That snap-back is important, because it tells us something very real: the bond market does not yet believe that lower mortgage rates are here to stay.

Right now, the idea that mortgage rates are “falling” is simply not accurate.

That doesn’t mean rates will never go down. It just means the conditions that normally drive mortgage rates lower are not fully in place yet.

How Mortgage Rates Really Move

Mortgage rates are not directly controlled by the Federal Reserve. This is one of the most misunderstood parts of the entire conversation.

The Fed controls the Fed Funds Rate, which influences things like credit cards, car loans, and short-term borrowing between banks. Mortgage rates, on the other hand, are driven primarily by the bond market, especially mortgage-backed securities.

When investors feel confident about the economy, they tend to move money into stocks and riskier assets. When they feel uncertain or fearful, they move money into bonds. When more money flows into bonds, bond prices rise, and interest rates fall.

This is where the disconnect happens for many consumers.

Lower mortgage rates usually do not arrive because everything is going great. They usually arrive when things start to feel shaky.

What Actually Brings Mortgage Rates Down

Historically, mortgage rates tend to move meaningfully lower when the Federal Reserve is done cutting interest rates, not while they are cutting. This is a critical distinction.

When the Fed finishes its rate-cutting cycle, it often means the economy is slowing more than expected. At that point, we commonly see two consecutive quarters of negative GDP growth, which is the technical definition of a recession.

During these periods, companies start laying people off. Job losses increase. The unemployment rate rises. Consumer confidence drops. Spending slows.

At the same time, stock markets typically struggle. Retirement accounts like 401(k)s take hits. Investors pull money out of equities and look for safer places to park their capital.

That capital often flows into bonds.

As bond demand increases, the cost of borrowing money decreases. That is when mortgage rates tend to fall in a meaningful way.

There is a strange irony here.

Mortgage rates usually get low when fewer people are working and fewer people feel financially secure enough to buy a home.

This has been the pattern for decades, and it has been especially consistent since around 2005.

Why Headlines Can Be Misleading

When political leaders or policymakers talk about supporting housing or lowering rates, markets often react emotionally at first. That initial reaction can cause a brief dip in rates.

But markets are forward-looking and brutally honest.

If investors do not believe that the policy will actually be implemented, sustained, or effective, rates move right back to where they were. That is exactly what we just witnessed.

Until there is real follow-through, or until economic data clearly weakens, mortgage rates are likely to remain range-bound.

Hope alone does not lower interest rates.

What This Means for Buyers and Homeowners

If you are waiting for mortgage rates to fall before making a move, it is important to understand what you are waiting for.

Lower rates often come with a weaker economy, more uncertainty, and tighter lending conditions. Job stability becomes more important. Underwriting can get stricter. Inventory can shift in unpredictable ways.

On the flip side, waiting too long can mean missing opportunities that exist right now, especially when fewer buyers are active and sellers are more negotiable.

There is no perfect moment. There is only the moment that aligns with your personal financial situation, job security, and long-term goals.

Final Thoughts

As of today, mortgage rates are not meaningfully falling. The recent headlines created a temporary reaction, not a lasting change.

If large-scale purchases of mortgage-backed securities actually materialize, that could influence rates lower. If the economy slows enough and the Fed completes its rate-cutting cycle, rates will likely follow.

But history is clear: mortgage rates usually get attractive when the broader economy is under stress.

Understanding that reality helps you make calmer, smarter decisions instead of chasing headlines.

If you have questions about how current mortgage rates affect your specific situation, the smartest move is to look at the numbers, the risks, and the opportunities together — with clear expectations and a long-term view.

Get a free rate quote today!

RELATED MORTGAGE ADVICE FROM SCOTT SHELDON

Capital Gains with a Mortgage – What Homeowners Need to Know

Many homeowners assume that selling a house with an existing mortgage complicates their tax situation—but…

Three Financial Reasons to Own a Home (That Your Lender Should Know)

Buying a home isn’t just about having a place to call your own—it’s also one…

Lower Rates vs. High Prices – The Tradeoff You Can’t Ignore

Everyone loves the idea of lower mortgage rates—and for good reason. A lower rate means…

Mortgage Rate Forecast: What to Watch and Why Timing Is Tough

Let’s face it—everyone wants to know when mortgage rates will drop. Whether you’re buying your…

View More from The Mortgage Files:

Row edge-slant Shape Decorative svg added to top
Row edge-slant Shape Decorative svg added to bottom

begin your mortgage journey with sonoma county mortgages

Let us make your mortgage experience easy. Trust our expertise to get you your best mortgage rate. Click below to start turning your home dreams into reality today!