Why Co-Signing a Loan Could Hurt Your Mortgage Plans

Co-signing a loan for someone might feel like the right thing to do, but it can have unintended consequences if you’re planning to get a mortgage or refinance your home. Whether it’s for a friend’s new car or a family member’s fancy motorcycle, co-signing puts their debt on your financial record, and that can cause significant problems with your debt-to-income (DTI) ratio. Let’s break down why this matters and how it can affect your mortgage plans.

How Co-Signing Impacts Your Debt-to-Income Ratio

When you co-sign for someone’s loan, the lender considers the monthly payment for that loan as part of your debt, even if you’re not the one making the payments. For example:

  • You co-sign for your friend’s motorcycle, and the monthly payment is $700.
  • That $700 per month shows up as your obligation when you apply for a mortgage or refinance.
  • Even though you’re not paying it, it’s calculated into your DTI ratio, which can make it appear higher than it actually is.

For most mortgage programs—FHA, VA, and conventional—lenders look closely at your DTI ratio to ensure you can handle your monthly obligations. If your DTI is too high, you might not qualify for the mortgage or refinance you want.

How to Prove You’re Not Responsible for Co-Signed Debt

If you’ve co-signed on a loan, there’s a way to remove its impact on your DTI ratio, but it requires documentation. You need to show that the person you co-signed for has been making the payments directly to the creditor for the last 12 months. Here’s what you’ll need:

  1. Bank Statements: Provide proof that payments have been made from a bank account you’re not on.
  2. Direct Payments: The creditor must receive payments directly from the borrower, not through you.

If you can prove this, the $700 monthly payment will no longer count against your DTI ratio. Without this proof, the lender has to assume you’re responsible for the debt.

How Co-Signed Debt Limits Your Borrowing Power

To put this into perspective, a $700 monthly payment is equivalent to approximately $100,000 in loan amount. This means that co-signed debt can significantly reduce your ability to qualify for:

  • Refinancing Your Home: Whether you’re planning an addition, a remodel, or a cash-out refinance, co-signed debt can limit how much you can borrow.
  • Purchasing a New Property: Co-signed debt reduces the amount of house you can afford by lowering your borrowing capacity.

The only ways around this are for the borrower to either pay off the debt or refinance it into their name to reduce the monthly obligation.

Why It’s Important to Think Twice Before Co-Signing

Co-signing might seem like a favor, but it can have long-lasting effects on your financial health. Here’s why you should reconsider:

  • Impacts Your Credit: The co-signed loan shows up on your credit report and affects your overall credit utilization.
  • Limits Your Financial Flexibility: Your ability to borrow for future goals, such as buying a home or refinancing, is reduced.
  • Requires Long-Term Monitoring: To avoid the co-signed debt impacting your mortgage, you need to track the borrower’s payments and ensure proper documentation.

Key Takeaways

If you’re considering co-signing a loan and might apply for a mortgage or refinance in the future, here are the main points to remember:

  1. Co-signed debt impacts your DTI ratio, reducing your borrowing capacity.
  2. To avoid this, ensure the borrower pays directly to the creditor for at least 12 months and keep documentation.
  3. Be cautious about co-signing, as it can limit your financial flexibility for years to come.

Looking for a mortgage? Get a free rate quote now!

RELATED MORTGAGE ADVICE FROM SCOTT SHELDON

"Suburban neighborhood with affordable homes and a scenic morning commute."

Could Commuting Be the Key to Affordable Homeownership?

For many families, finding an affordable home in their current city or town feels like…

Home inspector and contractor discussing a house inspection report."

Understanding Home Inspection Reports: Facts Buyers Must Know

Understanding Home Inspection Reports: Facts Buyers Must Know When buying a home, the inspection phase…

Family standing outside their new suburban home, smiling and celebrating homeownership made possible through a no down payment FHA program

How to Buy a House Without Income Limits or Government Red Tape

If you’re looking to buy a house but want to avoid the income limits and…

Side-by-side comparison of FHA and conventional loans with highlights of key differences, including PMI and down payments

FHA Loan vs. Conventional Loan: Which Is Best for Your Home Purchase?

Deciding between an FHA loan and a conventional loan for your home purchase is an…

View More from The Mortgage Files:

begin your mortgage journey with sonoma county mortgages

Let us make your mortgage experience easy. Trust our expertise to get you your best mortgage rate. Click below to start turning your home dreams into reality today!