How mortgage rate pricing works when rates decline

When interest rates are high, here’s how mortgage pricing works. Mortgage companies make money in two ways: the origination of the loan and the servicing of the loan, which involves collecting your monthly mortgage payments.

When interest rates are higher, say around 7%, mortgage aggregators assess the value of that mortgage. They think, “If rates are at 7% and we originate this loan, the servicing might last 45 to 67 months, for example.” However, if interest rates drop by 1%, the value of that servicing decreases, which introduces prepayment risk or early payoff (EPO) risk for the lender. This threatens the profitability of the loan.

As a result, points are often associated with loans in these environments. Lenders front-load the risk by charging points because, even if the loan is refinanced, the points paid make them whole. Given that the average interest rate over the last 30 years has been around 6%, it’s likely that rates may decrease, so lenders account for that with points.

Today’s mortgage rates often come with points, but the points required are generally lower. Recently, as the Federal Reserve cut interest rates and inflation threats have eased compared to six months ago, mortgages in the high 5% range might require 1 to 1.5 points. Previously, at 7%, those same mortgages would have required 2 points due to prepayment risk.

In today’s market, you can get a no-points loan at or just above 6%, with the likelihood of refinancing being low. The bond market and mortgage pricing have already factored in that rates may stay at these levels for about a year.

Looking forward, if you start seeing rates below 5.5% with lower points, that’s the market signaling a future decline in rates. When you get to a market where 5.375% or 5.5% loans come with no points, it’s a sign of where future mortgage rates are headed.

Bottom line: In the current market, you can get a preview of what’s to come by looking at a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage for a primary home without points, then comparing it to an option with points. The difference in rate is usually about 3/4 of a percent, meaning that paying a point and a half in costs is where the market expects future rates to be without points. This spread exists due to the risk lenders face if rates drop and loans get paid off early.

If you’re looking for a mortgage, get a free quote today!

RELATED MORTGAGE ADVICE FROM SCOTT SHELDON

Illustration showing a split scene of a rental apartment on one side and a house for sale on the other, representing the choice between renting and buyin

When to Rent Instead of Buy: Key Situations Where Renting Makes More Sense

Buying a home is often described as the ultimate step toward financial independence, but it…

Illustration of a house with a credit report and an appraisal document symbolizing the two main mortgage loan obstacles.

The Only Three Real Obstacles in the Loan Process: Credit/Income and Appraisal

For many homebuyers, getting a mortgage can feel like navigating a maze of paperwork and…

Illustration of a house with a credit card and mortgage paperwork, representing cash-out refinance to consolidate debt.

Does to make sense to cash refinance to consolidate debt?

Rising credit card balances and high-interest personal loans can put a strain on your monthly…

Illustration of a house with a dollar sign on one side and a stack of investment charts on the other, representing the choice between paying off a mortgage and investing

Should you pay off your mortgage or invest the cash instead?

When you come into extra cash—whether from a bonus, inheritance, or years of disciplined saving—you…

View More from The Mortgage Files:

begin your mortgage journey with sonoma county mortgages

Let us make your mortgage experience easy. Trust our expertise to get you your best mortgage rate. Click below to start turning your home dreams into reality today!